I'm interested in conversations about and I want to talk about
Know exactly what you want?
Show search

Notification

Error

USE OF RECTAL SPACER IN LOW DOSE BRACHYTHERAPY.

User
Posted 07 Feb 2025 at 08:03

Hi all, I was wondering of those of you who have had LDR BRACHYTHERAPY did you have or were you offered a rectal spacer.  When I mentioned it to my consultant he said it would not be used as there was no evidence of its benefits, which surprised me.

Many thanks, John

User
Posted 07 Feb 2025 at 12:12

I didn't have LDR (I had HDR and EBRT) and I studied physics.

The strength of radiation falls off very rapidly with increasing distance from the radioactive source. For LDR seeds the effective range of radiation is about 4mm. Your bowel will be outside that range.

I know there are warnings about having pets or children on your lap, so you are probably thinking the radiation at about 15cm from your prostate is still dangerous, but the reality is that the radiation dose a child on your lap would receive is about 0.1% of the dose in your prostate (no point in exposing a child to that completely avoidable risk though). Your bowel at about 1cm from your prostate is probably getting about 5% the dose your prostate is getting.

With EBRT the figures are quite different. As your bowel is near your prostate it will be getting exactly the same dose as your prostate (100%). By firing at different angles they can get this down to about 20% the dose. By using a rectal spacer they can get it to about 10% the dose.

Even with EBRT it is considered the benefit of a rectal spacer is not worth while, or to put it another way, your bowel can tolerate 20% of radiation, and bringing that down to 10% doesn't make a significant improvement. So with LDR which is only getting 5% the dose the operation to insert the spacer would probably be more dangerous than the benefit you would get.

 

Dave

User
Posted 07 Feb 2025 at 13:33

Many thanks Dave, just the sort of information I’ve come to expect from contributors on this forum, that all seems to make sense.  Had a quick look at your bio, glad to see everything’s stable with you, hope it continues that way.  Thanks again, John

 
Forum Jump  
©2025 Prostate Cancer UK