Notification

Error

Sometimes the best treatment is none at all.

User
Posted 20 Nov 2025 at 00:00

I have been weighing up my options carefully over the last couple of years since my BCR was confirmed. My doubling time was slow (18 months) and I only had 2 active pelvic nodes. So I had  SRT which resulted in a 30% drop in my PSA to 2.4ng/ml after 3 months. A bit early to be definitive of course but encouraging. Unfortunately subsequent PSA testing at six post TX showed the PSA dip was a blip as my PSA had returned to pre treatment levels. So what to do if anything?

For clarification I am 75 years, my health status is poor, with a multitude of comorbidity, the most salient of which is heart failure.  Following a discussion with my Radiation Oncologist yesterday we have decided on a softly softly approach to try to maintain a reasonable quality of life while I am able to. To that end it we have decided against the usual first and second line treatements. The rationale being that flair in my heart failure would be guaranteed. Thus our plan of action is PSA monitoring every 3/12. A CT and perhaps a Bone Scan looking for new lesions in a year's time. Any new lesions found to be treated by another dose of SRT. So that is where I am currently at.

The reason for my post is to make people aware that comorbidity can have an impact far in excess of PCa. If my assumptions are incorrect and my PCa does matamorphosis from a kitten in to a raging tiger, I do have the assisted dying protocol which is available now in all states of Australia. I just recently observed the assisted dying protocol with an old friend who died with a smile on his face, following his dog licking his hand. It was a dignified end to a good life.

I am happy to answer genuine questions. 

 

Edited by moderator 20 Nov 2025 at 12:29  | Reason: Thanks for your post. We appreciate you sharing your experience. We’ve approved it but removed the l

User
Posted 20 Nov 2025 at 00:00

I have been weighing up my options carefully over the last couple of years since my BCR was confirmed. My doubling time was slow (18 months) and I only had 2 active pelvic nodes. So I had  SRT which resulted in a 30% drop in my PSA to 2.4ng/ml after 3 months. A bit early to be definitive of course but encouraging. Unfortunately subsequent PSA testing at six post TX showed the PSA dip was a blip as my PSA had returned to pre treatment levels. So what to do if anything?

For clarification I am 75 years, my health status is poor, with a multitude of comorbidity, the most salient of which is heart failure.  Following a discussion with my Radiation Oncologist yesterday we have decided on a softly softly approach to try to maintain a reasonable quality of life while I am able to. To that end it we have decided against the usual first and second line treatements. The rationale being that flair in my heart failure would be guaranteed. Thus our plan of action is PSA monitoring every 3/12. A CT and perhaps a Bone Scan looking for new lesions in a year's time. Any new lesions found to be treated by another dose of SRT. So that is where I am currently at.

The reason for my post is to make people aware that comorbidity can have an impact far in excess of PCa. If my assumptions are incorrect and my PCa does matamorphosis from a kitten in to a raging tiger, I do have the assisted dying protocol which is available now in all states of Australia. I just recently observed the assisted dying protocol with an old friend who died with a smile on his face, following his dog licking his hand. It was a dignified end to a good life.

I am happy to answer genuine questions. 

 

Edited by moderator 20 Nov 2025 at 12:29  | Reason: Thanks for your post. We appreciate you sharing your experience. We’ve approved it but removed the l

User
Posted 17 Feb 2026 at 04:42

Well my six weekly psa see saw pattern continues. When I reached BCR back in March 2024 my psa was at 2.4 ng/ml. By October that year my psa was 3.2 ng/ml. In February of 2025 it had again risen to 3.55 ng/ml. In March when I had a Radiation Oncology consult, the pas value was 3.61 ng/ml. At that time I was treated by SRT to two pelvic lymph nodes that had been previously identified by a PET Scan. Following the SRT treatment in July 2025 was PSA dropped to 2.76 ng/ml. By November my psa increased again to about the pre treatment level of 3.40 ng/ml. In December of 2025 my psa again dropped to 2.77 ng/ml. February 2026 and my psa again returned to pre treatment level, 3.35 ng/ml. So while the spikes are interesting, essentially they are of of no significance clinically at the present point of time. But is is heartening to know that my psa presently appears to be in a circular orbit holding pattern. The Lancet of 16th of Feb 2026 has an article on developing a nomogram for men in my situation. So maybe a useful tool may be forthcoming in the future.

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanonc/article/PIIS1470-2045(25)00717-X/abstract?rss=yes

 

User
Posted 06 Jun 2026 at 01:11

Well it has been about one and a quarter years since SRT to my two hot pelvic lymph nodes. We decided not to treat my primary PCa cancer in my prostate as it is tiny. I recently had a CT scan without contrast and a bone scan. The CT scan has been reported on and I was stunned to read the report. Essentially my PCa recurrence is in remission.

Lymph Nodes: No size significant pelvic or retroperitoneal lymphadenopathy. Unchanged appearance of the elongated lymph nodes in both inguinal regions, not meeting the size criteria for enlargement. No size significant mediastinal or axillary lymphadenopathy. Metastases: No suspicious lung nodule or mass. The liver, gallbladder, pancreas, spleen, and adrenal glands define normally.

I will report on my bone scan and new PSA test when I have them to hand.

And no I have not done anything differently, medication, lifestyle, all remain as is, and I live within the constraints of my heart failure. Still walking 4km a day on the flat.

Show Most Thanked Posts
User
Posted 02 Jan 2026 at 23:07

Well just when I thought my journey was all organised my most recent PSA has decided to head south again by the same 30% margin? Well while most welcomed, this has my physicians and myself somewhat dumbfounded. A see saw pattern seems to be emerging every six weeks. So it would appear that my BCR is neither progressing nor regressing at this stage. The catalyst? No idea, as the therapies for my co-morbidities have remained static. Stress? Well I really don't have any. I am quite comfortable with where I am on my journey. TBC.

User
Posted 03 Jan 2026 at 03:36
Your PCa seems to be taking an unusual path but you have thought things through and as you say if it gets get really bad, you have the enlightened assisted dying in OZ. Unfortunately, in the UK Parliament has talked a lot about it then it gets put on the back burner like so many other questions they don't want to answer. My wife died of dementia, pneumonia and starvation last year, When I visited her in the care home I could hear her screaming before I even got to her room. This continued throughout my visit and after I left until exhausted she fell asleep. Had assisted dying been provided in the UK, she would have not have had to endure several weeks of pain and anguish. PCa can also be a rotten death and whether it's because of this or something else, I hope the Bill will be enacted here soon.
Barry
User
Posted 18 Jan 2026 at 23:24

Hi jfd

Can I ask what specific treatment you were advised would flare up your heart failure?

My dad is in a similar situation to you where he has multiple health issues, one of which is heart failure. He was prescribed Zoladex 12 months ago and since then he’s been admitted in hospital twice for fluid on his lungs which he had never experienced before starting Zoladex. He’s now rapidly declined and barely has the energy to get out of bed and we are wondering if this is being made worse by the Zoladex.

We don’t seem to have had as good advice as you regarding the heart failure and due to the multiple health issues we are just getting passed round in circles.

Any advice you could give would be much appreciated, thanks Lucy 

User
Posted 22 Jan 2026 at 06:27

Reply to Old Barry,

                                 Barry in all states of Australia assisted dying is only available to persons able to make an informed decision about ending their life. Dementia would be a red flag I am afraid. The other proviso is that the person has received medical advice to the effect that their lifespan is of six months or less. However the time frame is extended to 12 months for MND and subsets.

                                 The person if possible ingests the Pentobarbital orally. If that is not possible either a Medical Practitioner or a Nurse Practitioner may administer the lethal dose intravenously. 

                                 I am due for a further PSA test in a few weeks (6 weekly intervals for the present) and we shall see if we have stability or another rise.

Edited by member 22 Jan 2026 at 06:55  | Reason: Not specified

User
Posted 22 Jan 2026 at 06:51

Reply to Lucy29

Hello Lucy,

                  The usage of ADT has been contraindicated in PCa patients with heart failure for a good period of time. General consensus is of the view that ADT in it's various forms may give rise to the development of heart failure in some individuals. So while the risk is known, treating physicians tend to try to balance treatment on the basis of dealing with the most life threatening co-morbidy. If PCa is rampant and heart failure in stage 1 or 2, then ADT may be considered appropriate and conversely visa versa as in my case. 

                 Forgive me Lucy, but I am trying to simplify what is a very complex medical situation. I think you should have a good chat with your Dad's physician. 

                  

Edited by member 22 Jan 2026 at 06:59  | Reason: Not specified

User
Posted 17 Feb 2026 at 04:42

Well my six weekly psa see saw pattern continues. When I reached BCR back in March 2024 my psa was at 2.4 ng/ml. By October that year my psa was 3.2 ng/ml. In February of 2025 it had again risen to 3.55 ng/ml. In March when I had a Radiation Oncology consult, the pas value was 3.61 ng/ml. At that time I was treated by SRT to two pelvic lymph nodes that had been previously identified by a PET Scan. Following the SRT treatment in July 2025 was PSA dropped to 2.76 ng/ml. By November my psa increased again to about the pre treatment level of 3.40 ng/ml. In December of 2025 my psa again dropped to 2.77 ng/ml. February 2026 and my psa again returned to pre treatment level, 3.35 ng/ml. So while the spikes are interesting, essentially they are of of no significance clinically at the present point of time. But is is heartening to know that my psa presently appears to be in a circular orbit holding pattern. The Lancet of 16th of Feb 2026 has an article on developing a nomogram for men in my situation. So maybe a useful tool may be forthcoming in the future.

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanonc/article/PIIS1470-2045(25)00717-X/abstract?rss=yes

 

User
Posted 06 Jun 2026 at 01:11

Well it has been about one and a quarter years since SRT to my two hot pelvic lymph nodes. We decided not to treat my primary PCa cancer in my prostate as it is tiny. I recently had a CT scan without contrast and a bone scan. The CT scan has been reported on and I was stunned to read the report. Essentially my PCa recurrence is in remission.

Lymph Nodes: No size significant pelvic or retroperitoneal lymphadenopathy. Unchanged appearance of the elongated lymph nodes in both inguinal regions, not meeting the size criteria for enlargement. No size significant mediastinal or axillary lymphadenopathy. Metastases: No suspicious lung nodule or mass. The liver, gallbladder, pancreas, spleen, and adrenal glands define normally.

I will report on my bone scan and new PSA test when I have them to hand.

And no I have not done anything differently, medication, lifestyle, all remain as is, and I live within the constraints of my heart failure. Still walking 4km a day on the flat.

User
Posted 06 Jun 2026 at 09:25

Originally Posted by: Online Community Member
 The CT scan has been reported on and I was stunned to read the report. Essentially my PCa recurrence is in remission.

Thanks for the update, jfd. Terrific news. I hope that your bone scan results and PSA tests are as good.👍

User
Posted 08 Jun 2026 at 04:56

Bone scan has now been reported on.

Head & Neck: No abnormal avid osteoblastic focus in the skull, facial bones, mandible, or in the cervical spine.

Thorax & Upper Limbs: Mild degerative pattern of uptake in the sternoclavicular and acromioclavicular joints. Physiological pattern of uptake in the clavicles and upper limb bones. A small focus of low grade uptake at the anterior aspect of the left 7th rib is non specific. Uptake in remainder of ribs is non specific.

The small focus uptake on the left 7th rib is an old # osasioned when I suffered the indignity of falling between the wharf and my yacht years ago.

Lumbar spine, Pelvis & Lower Limbs: Physiological pattern of uptake in the lumbar spine, pelvic bones, hips, and in the lower limb bones. Moderate arthritic pattern of uptake in the first MTP joints.

Summary: No evidence of oesteoblastic bony metastatic pathology. A small focal activity of the 7th anteriorly is likely related to prior bony injury. 

 

My thoughts: My prostate cancer first surfaced in November of 2006 during my annual physical with my GP. I was 56 years of age at the time. My PSA was elevated 6.0 ng/ml and DRE indicated hardening of the entire left hemisphere of my enlarged prostate. My PCa was staged at T2B following biopsy. I was treated with 9 months of neo adjuvant ADT (Lucrin as it is known in Australia), and 70 Gy of Radiation. My PSA was uneventful for 12 years then it commenced to rise ever so slowly over subsequent years. I reached the threshold for BCR (2.25 ng/ml) in 2024. I underwent a PSMA Pet Scan in October 2014. Small low grade uptake in apical prostate. Very small volume disease not requiring any salvage local treatment. No bony mets seen. One iliac region nodal uptake (SUV 12.14) activity. Node was left internal iliac node. Radiation planned for local node for temporary PSA control however during planning CT the node (size 4mm) was unable to be identified to target. Thus RT cancelled and a second PSMA scan scheduled in 3 months. Second PSMA in Feb 2025. Interval increase in avidity ( now SUV max 16.85) and a second node ( SUV 2.73, obturator node) was identified. So in a further 3 months we now have firther progression in the known node and a new node identified. Radiotherapy was given to both nodes (30 Gy and 25 Gy). PSA following Tx at 3/12 dropped 30%. PSA doubling time was never really an issue (18 to 24 months). And so here we are now stuck in a holding pattern with no active treatment for PCa. PSA bloods will be taken this week and I will report on that when available.

So my PCa journey will enter it's 20th year this year and with an initial staging of T2b, Gleason 7 (4+3), I never really expected to be in this situation in my twilight years. Still no requirement for ADT currently is a big plus, particularly give my heart failure issues.

 

Edited by member 08 Jun 2026 at 04:59  | Reason: Not specified

User
Posted 08 Jun 2026 at 05:13

All very encouraging.  Do please continue to keep us informed and good luck!  Anthony.  

User
Posted 08 Jun 2026 at 06:13

I have posted my journey on here in the belief that it may be of interest to some fellow members on here. I again find it necessary to reiterate that my focus is in science. To be clear, I have no interest whatsoever in social support, pats on the back, well wishes, and the like. "This is my story". I should be able to tell it as I wish, free from the well intentioned, but very irritating, unproductive sideline comments of you know who. I have history with this person. Their post adds absolutely nothing to the content of my story.

Moderators if you choose to delete my post, then I also request you delete the post that I refer to. You no doubt know who I mean.

Moderators you recently invited me to contribute to an article and if you are wondering why I did not respond, you have your answer.

Moderators should you value the post in question as having greater interest than my own and not remove the said post, then either delete my entire thread or I will alter my contents so as it is useless to any reader.

I am really fed up with the fellow's stalking and it has to stop. Thank you.

User
Posted 08 Jun 2026 at 06:22

If any reader has a genuine question relating to my story, I would be happy to respond with my experiences. 

User
Posted 12 Jun 2026 at 00:32

Well my PSA has been reported on. Again the see saw pattern continues, this time with a drop from 3.35 ng/ml to 2.9 ng/ml. Suffice to say the holding pattern continues without the need for any ADT whatsoever. So on the evidence to hand we have no PCa progression over the last one and one quarter years. Long may it continue.

User
Posted 16 Jun 2026 at 08:25

I had my oncology consult today and we reviewed my scans and psa. We decided to wait until my psa reached 5 and then have another PSMA Scan (my 3rd). With my current doubling time of 18 to 24 months, the scan won't be anytime soon. We also agreed to continue no ADT, and review our treatment plan if and when any new PCa mets warranted it. Next consult in 6/12. Thus far I am comfortable with our approach.

 
Forum Jump  
©2026 Prostate Cancer UK