My sense, from my OH’s experiences, is that the Tena pads worked best. I bought every kind I could order for him on Amazon, in the different shapes, and even some women's pads. The Tena pads failed when the volume was too great. The same was true for me with women’s pads back in the day. From those (fortunately few but utterly humiliating) experiences, I knew always to pack a spare change of clothes, plus wipes and tissues (and plastic bags for any wet clothes), for my husband when we went out, before he regained continence. He keeps a spare set of clothes etc in his office as well, just in case.