Notification

Error

Artificial Intelligence use

User
Posted 28 Apr 2026 at 22:40

Good evening,


Does anyone make use of Artificial Intelligence tools on this forum? 


Below is what ChatGPT initially thought of my condition.  It gave a surprisingly good plan and options that were almost what the Oncologist had offered.


Here's the first stage of our conversation.  It went on quite a lot further.


..............................................................................................









Peter2016:  'Psa test results after prostatectomy undetectable <0.05 between Dec 2016 to Aug 2021. Dec 2021 0.06. Dec 2024 0.12. Feb 2026 0.15. What do you think?'





 











ChatGPT response:  'I’ll be straight with you: this pattern is not unusual after a prostatectomy, but it does deserve careful follow-up rather than being ignored.


After prostate removal, PSA is expected to be essentially undetectable. A commonly used definition of biochemical recurrence is a PSA of ≥0.2 ng/mL confirmed on repeat testing.


What your numbers suggest



  • 2016–2021: Undetectable (<0.05) → excellent, expected outcome

  • Dec 2021: 0.06 → tiny rise, often watched rather than acted on

  • Dec 2024: 0.12 → gradual increase

  • Feb 2026: 0.15 → still below recurrence threshold, but clearly rising


So:



  • You’re still below the formal recurrence definition (0.2)

  • But there is a slow upward trend over several years


Why that matters


The key factor isn’t just the number—it’s the trend and doubling time. Yours appears:



  • Very slow rising (over ~4–5 years)

  • That generally points to low-volume or slow-growing residual disease, if anything is present at all


That’s quite different from a rapid rise, which would be more concerning.


Typical clinical thinking


A urologist or oncologist would usually:



  • Continue regular PSA monitoring (often every 3–6 months now)

  • Watch for:

    • PSA reaching 0.2 and rising

    • Or a shortening doubling time




They may start discussing salvage radiotherapy before PSA hits 0.2 in some cases, especially if:



  • You were originally higher risk

  • Pathology showed positive margins or spread outside the prostate


The encouraging part



  • Your PSA stayed undetectable for 5 years, which is a good sign

  • The rise is very gradual, which often correlates with better outcomes if treatment is needed


What I’d suggest you do



  • Don’t panic—but don’t ignore it either

  • Make sure you’re under follow-up (urology or oncology)

  • Ask specifically about:

    • PSA doubling time

    • When they would consider salvage radiotherapy

    • Whether imaging (like PSMA PET) would be useful if it rises further






If you want, tell me:



  • Your original Gleason score

  • Whether there were positive margins / lymph node involvement


That makes a big difference in interpreting this trend and what doctors are likely to recommend next.'


...............................................................................................


My opinion;  After using it quite a lot it has a surprising amount of knowledge and can come across as very authoritative. But if it's a question with repercussions it needs to be challenged with questions and questioning the answers as one wrong fact or mis-interpretation can put it on a different route.  After all that the final decision is one that you take as to whether to get professional advice.


There are other tools such as Google Gemini and Claude.








User
Posted 29 Apr 2026 at 08:13

Hi, Peter.


I think AI is an incredible resource but it does rely on how you question it. I use Google Gemini  but ALWAYS check the scientific papers it cites in it's replies.


I read that they intend to use AI more and more in prostate cancer diagnosis, for interpreting biopsy samples etc. 


On three recent visits to our local surgery, three different doctors have used Dr Google during the appointment.


On the downside, I fear the affect AI may have on the job market. Two of my sons have scientific based careers.  They both fear that AI will eventually make them redundant.


I hate how scammers are using AI to try and disrupt this forum.

Edited by member 29 Apr 2026 at 09:17  | Reason: Rewording

User
Posted 29 Apr 2026 at 21:35
I love Grok, it's similar to the others but knows which sex has a penis.
 
Forum Jump  
©2026 Prostate Cancer UK