Hello all, thanks so much for all the great support on this forum. I've had a confusing experience this last year.
Background - 49M. Father had prostate cancer so got PSA test at health check. PSA ranged from 2.25 to 3.4 across 3 separate readings, so forwarded for MRI. Prostate normal size at 28cc.
The NHS radiologist identified a small 1cm lesion in transition zone, which they graded Likert 4. Vibe was very much 'this is likely to be cancer so we need to biopsy'. So I had the biopsy, 16 cores transperineal which I found pretty humiliating and uncomfortable, tbh.
Result? No cancer found in any core, no PIN, very mild inflammation, probably due to prostatitis.
Obviously very relieved but... On reflection I felt confused about the experience, so I decided to get a 2nd opinion (which I had to pay for privately at one of the London university hospitals). The MRI was reviewed by their specialist prostate pathologist who said they saw no suspicious lesion on the scan. Based on this and other factors, the urologist said he would not have biopsied me AT ALL.
So I feel like I've had a traumatic procedure and a hell of a lot of worry, both of which could have been avoided. I understand MRI scans are subjective to some extent, and the NHS probably err on the side of caution, but the difference between a Likert 4 and no cancer is really quite a lot.
Worst of all, it's made me feel like I can't trust the diagnosis process going forward at my local hospital (Treliske in Cornwall). Has anyone else been through something similar? What did you do?
Edited by member 19 Nov 2026 at 12:22
| Reason: added hospital