Morning Simon
It would certainly make life easier if you knew what the eventual outcome of surgery or RT would be , say in 10 years time, so that making a life-changing decision would not be so difficult. Although I was only on Active Surveillance for 6 months before my operation, I now believe that I had the symptoms of prostate cancer ( weak urine flow , going regularly to the loo during the day, but not during the night) at least 10 years earlier. And , I have no doubt, I would have probably have had a raised PSA level if I had been tested at age 54 instead of 60 . So, having at least 13 years treatment free is, I think, a bit of a bonus.
My understanding is that both RT and surgery have the same results in terms of life expectancy, though surgery does initially have more side effects. As I have previously mentioned, I chose surgery because I liked the idea that the cancer would-hopefully- be totally removed, that I could undergo RT if, by chance, the operation was not successful and because I never liked the idea of being treated with a dangerous substance. Additionally, by having your prostate removed you are able to determine the actual final grade of cancer (it could be higher than that found during the biopsies). Two close friends of mine both opted for surgery at Addenbrookes in 2010 and both 11 years on are still alive (one is 81 , the other is 79) and both regained ED and full continence. Though, that said, both have in the last couple of years started to wear a pad again for small leaks. My incontinence, 5 weeks on, is still improving and I am now probably 80/90% back to where I was before the operation. ED wise, I am beginning to get a little hard and do have an orgasm, though, obviously, no semen is ejaculated.
The robotic surgeons at Addenbrookes have a very good reputation and both undertake a high number of operations each year. I cannot fault the treatment I received from Addenbrookes and was so satisfied that I donated £1000 to their "buy a robot" appeal.
It is not easy making the decision as you do not know the eventual outcome , but take account of what you have read, go with what you think is right for you and don't keep thinking "if only".
Keep us appraised of how you get on
Ivan